Here’s an argument map of philosopher William Irwin’s “God is a Question, Not an Answer” from The Stone (a New York Times opinion forum).¬†Once again, visualizing arguments helps us talk intelligently about a difficult issue!

How accurate is my reconstruction of his argument? How charitable is it?

How about Irwin’s argument itself–is it strong? Why or why not? Do you agree with his claims? Is his evidence relevant and sufficient?